One of the pastors at my church recently made the statement that “the opposite of faith isn’t doubt, it is certainty.”
Through my 27 years of working in the church, I have seen over and over again this statement ring true.
The first time I learned this lesson was in college when I had a professor ask me “Kevin, do you believe your understanding of God is 100% correct?” The answer to that question is obviously no (hopefully it is obvious). It would be rather arrogant to think that I have God 100% figured out. When I told my professor that no, I don’t think my understanding of God is 100% correct; his follow up question disarmed me a bit. He simply said, “well…what do you think you have wrong?”
Up until that point, within my religious studies at Greensboro College, I had been rather certain. I had been taught that doubt was the opposite of faith, so I left no room for it. The problem is, certainty wasn’t allowing for any tension in my faith, and I have learned that our faith grows the most through tension. Much like working out at a gym, if we don’t provide tension to our bodies, our bodies do not have the opportunity to get stronger. If we provide no tension to our faith, our faith won't grow.
I left that conversation much more open to listening to other people’s understanding of God. I allowed tension, even when it was uncomfortable.
These days, I spend far less time on social media than I used to. As I scrolled through comments and posts this morning, it hit me one of the things that I struggle with the most on social media. I struggle with certainty. Primarily, I struggle with the certainty of my fellow brothers and sisters in Christ.
Through my years in ministry, I have had the opportunity to work with lots of young people wresting with their faith. One very consistent theme throughout the years, is that they love Jesus. They love Jesus’ message. They love the way Jesus treated others and that he simplified the “law" to "Love God with all your heart, soul, strength, and mind, and love your neighbors as yourself." To them, it is simple...if you love God with all you have, and love your neighbor as yourself...you won't lie, cheat, steal, murder, gossip, etc.
They may love Jesus, but they really really struggle with the church. In a conversation with a young man that had gone off to college, but drifted from the institutional church, he said something that has always stuck with me.
“It doesn’t bother me that the church is full of hypocrites, it bothers me that the church is full of people trying to prove they aren’t hypocrites.”
In our conversation, he explained that he expected the church to be full of broken people…after all scripture tells that “All have sinned and fallen short of the glory of God.” (Romans 3:23. This young man expected the church to be full of broken people…because we are all broken, but said every church he had visited was full of people trying to prove they had it all together. He quoted 2 Corinthians 12:9, “But he said to me, ‘My grace is sufficient for you, for my power is made perfect in weakness.’ Therefore, I will boast all the more gladly about my weaknesses, so that Christ’s power may rest on me.”
He struggled because he found no vulnerability. He struggled because he found people compartmentalizing their faith…only applying Truth to certain areas of their lives. He struggled because he saw the church taking a zero tolerance approach to some sin, and completely ignoring others. Conveniently, the sin that was generally ignored was how folks in that church struggled with sin, and the sin that there was zero tolerance for was sin that folks didn’t struggle with or understand.
Like to gossip? Come on, we will mask our gossip as prayer request! You belong!
Struggle with drunkenness? Well, get your life together and then we would love to welcome you.
Don’t mind a little favoritism or backbiting? Come on (well, as long as you are in the same socioeconomic status as us and want to bad mouth the people we don’t like)! You belong!
Wait, you are living with your girlfriend/boyfriend? Nope, not here, we don’t tolerate sexual immorality.
Want to hate a certain group of people? Well, we hate them too! Let’s go! You belong!
You want to welcome all people and leave the judging to God? Get that out of here…the church needs accountability!
Accountability…Through the years when I have pushed folks on this topic, accountability is often what is thrown back to me. “If as a church, we don’t hold people accountable, then we will morally degrade and become secular…no different than the rest of the world.” I agree, I think accountability is important. However, I believe strongly that accountability is most appropriate and has the greatest effect when it is done in the midst of relationship. The better and deeper we know each other, the easier it is to hold each other accountable without resentment. My close friend and family can hold me accountable in ways that someone I just met cannot. I think the key to that is trust…you cannot have accountability without trust…and you cannot have trust without relationship. Accountability outside of relationship is, well…judgement. If I am holding people accountable that I don’t know, I lack the context and relationship for accountability to be effective. I think it is important to note that accountability is only effective when it is in a relationship that allows accountability to go both ways. Too often in church, we are all about holding other people accountable, but don’t you dare try to hold me accountable.
It is impossible to develop a relationship with someone that you villainize or exclude. If I start off a conversation with “you are an idiot” or “you are evil”…I should not be surprised if the other person doesn’t really listen to or respect what I have to say. Dehumanizing the “other side” isn’t the work of the Holy Spirit…it is the work of the flesh. Dehumanizing or villainizing the other side ignores the fact that “the other side” are also children of God…Children that God deeply loves.
Watching post on social media lately…we as Christians seem awfully certain. We think being confident in our faith means we have to come across as certain in our faith. We think if we don’t come across as certain, that our faith looks weak. And if our faith looks weak…our witness becomes weak. However, I believe wholeheartedly that our certainty is killing our witness.
Our certainty isn’t bring people to God…it is driving them away from God. My favorite quote is by Oliver Goldsmith, “You can preach a better sermon with your life than with your lips.” Ultimately, the heart of this quote is that you cannot preach a sermon if your life doesn’t match what your lips are saying. Our message of God’s love falls short when we show hate. Our message of accountability falls short when we don’t allow others to hold us accountable. Our message of Jesus being Lord of our life, falls short when others see that we only allow Jesus to be Lord of only parts of our lives.
We are awfully certain of ourselves, thinking we are the only ones that understand God fully, and we flash this certainty while compartmentalizing our faith. It is obvious to those on the outside that we are allowing God to only touch certain parts of our lives. We act like only the sins of others is the problem, and our sins aren’t a big deal. If you sin like me, you belong…if you sin differently than me, then you are evil and need to be hated. We are outraged when it is convenient, but ignore other issues when it doesn’t fit our narrative. Too many of us are allowing our politics to shape our faith rather than our faith shape our politics. We are using a political platform to justify how we read scripture, rather than allowing scripture (through the Holy Spirit) to guide our politics. We seem to think the way forward is to drive people to our political party. If we can just get them to agree with our platform, they will find salvation. If we can just get people to agree with us, they will find salvation.
But our salvation doesn’t come
…through a political party
…through certainty
…our own goodness
…our own “rightness”
it comes
…through repentance (which can only come with vulnerability) of our sins.
…through God’s grace.
…through the cross.
If I am certain of anything, it is that we are not going to lead people to God by leading them to a political party, a certain platform, or a certain way of thinking. We will only lead people to God when we lead them to the cross. We best lead people to the cross through relationship. I’ve had the honor of leading many people to the cross. I’ve had the pleasure of seeing people accept God’s into their life for the first time. Every single time I’ve had that honor…it is because I’ve had a relationship with that individual.
Our way forward is through building deeper relationships. It isn’t an easy road, because relationships are hard. True relationships are messy. True relationships require honesty, vulnerability, acts of service done in love, encouragement, compromise, selflessness, respect, humility, and more.
If you want a great passage to guide you in how to build deeper relationships as a people of faith…1 Corinthians 13 gives us a great blueprint. Yes, it is a passage often read at weddings. However, in full context, it is a passage that immediately follows Paul’s instructions how to have unity and celebrate diversity in the church body. 1 Corinthians 13 is great instructions for how to have healthy love within a marriage, but it is intended to be instructions on how to love well within the body of Christ.
If I speak in tongues of men or of angels, but do not have love, I am only a resounding gong or a clanging cymbal.
If I have the gift of prophecy and can fathom all mysteries and all knowledge, and if I have a faith that can move mountains, but do not have love, I am nothing.
If I give all I possess to the poor and give over my body to hardship that I may boast, but do not have love, I gain nothing.
Love is patient
Love is kind
It does not envy
It does not boast
It is not proud
It does not dishonor others
It is not self-seeking
It is not easily angered
It keeps no record of wrongs
Love does not delight in evil
Love rejoices with the truth
It always protects
Always trusts
Always hopes
Always perseveres
Love never fails.
But where there are prophecies, they will cease
Where there are tongues, they will be stilled
Where there is knowledge, it will pass
For we know in part
We prophesy in part
But when completeness comes
What is in part disappears
When I was a child,
I talked like a child
I thought like a child
I reasoned like a child
When I became a man
I put the ways of childhood behind me
For now we see only a reflection as in a mirror
Then we shall see face to face.
Now I know in part
Then I shall know full
Even as I am fully known
And now these three things remain:
Faith
Hope
Love
But the greatest of these is love
Let this be your litmus test.
Let this be your measure of faith.
If you are to be certain in anything…be certain in this.
Because the opposite of faith isn’t doubt…
…it is certainty.